Transgender Inclusion in Libraries Webinar Highlights
Published: April 16, 2019 by Havilah Steinman
This week we welcome a guest post by Dr. Michele Villagran on the iStudent blog. She’s a member of the iSchool’s Diversity Committee and helped organize a webcast on transgender patrons and library services. The webcast was wildly popular and reached maximum enrollment. Dr. Villagran shares highlights of the webcast with us.
On March 25, 2019, the San José State University School of Information’s Diversity Committee hosted a webinar entitled, “Transgender Inclusion in Libraries” to continue our celebration of diversity and appreciation of inclusive excellence. The session received overwhelming interest from students, alumni, faculty and practitioners, and peers within the library and information science profession from across the United States.
Reed Garber-Pearson, Micah Kehrein, Sunny Kim and Bean Yogi were the four dynamic panelists for the session. As a condensed version of this workshop, the two main goals of the session were around learning about transgender, queer and gender non-conforming peoples’ experiences, and exploration of ideas for creating safe spaces through language, programs and policies.
Bean opened the session with a land acknowledgement of the area from which the presenters were broadcasting from, the homeland of the Duwamish tribe to recognize and appreciate the indigenous peoples. Our speakers each use the pronouns they/them/theirs, which are the words that are used to refer to someone. Other examples include she, he or z.
Common language and terminology was discussed to ensure we were speaking to each other versus across each other. It was important to note that languages may change over time and that gender as a binary is false even though in society, gender is defined as binary (male/female). The following definitions guided the discussion:
- Transgender: an overarching term for people whose gender identity differs from what is associated with gender they were assigned at birth
- Cisgender: used for people who identify with the gender they were assigned at birth
- Transgender woman (or trans woman): reflects a person who is woman and was assigned male at birth and similarly for a transgender man (or trans man), a person who is a man and assigned female at birth
- Non-binary or genderqueer: people that experience their gender identity outside the binary and as the presenters note that no two experiences are the same
- Gender non-conforming: person whose appearance or behavior does not conform to expectations of society about what is appropriate of their gender
- Transition: complex process that may include personal, medical and legal steps. It is your personal journey to being yourself as fully as possible as noted by Sunny.
- Intersex: general term for a person that is born with a reproductive or sexual anatomy that doesn’t fit with the typical definitions of male or female
Micah shared with us the Gender Unicorn, which illustrates gender identity, expression, sex assigned at birth, physical attraction and emotional attraction. While this graphic is helpful and was created by a trans student resource organization, the presenters showed it in order to illustrate the complexity of identities within each of the categories.
Bean expressed that having a trans or nonbinary identity is a true mystery. There is no one size fits all. Trust the pronouns that someone tells you – they are telling you who they are. Transgender are intersectional and often include all races, all socioeconomic classes, all ages, etc. When thinking about transgender inclusion in libraries, we should consider having programs and services which are inclusive of trans people as they are a part of our communities.
Micah further discussed why this is important for librarians. We work with all different customers and interact with trans folks. If a trans person is misgendered those could escalated into a challenging situation. Misgendering happens regularly to trans folks and it can often be harmful and hurtful. Learning to use nonbinary gender inclusive language as discussed earlier is a first step to make our libraries more inclusive and welcoming. Assessing your institution is a way you can determine how your organization can do better. You may have transgender coworkers and not be aware of this, so continually being misgendered and create a hostile work environment. Transgender folks also face their own barriers such as with health insurance.
Reed offered best practices for how we can make safer spaces where trans folks can be more seen and acknowledged in our workplaces. First relates to misgendering and assuming incorrect gender. It is better to ask someone rather than assume. Once you are informed of that gender, use that gender or use the correct pronoun. Words are very important to trans folks who have to experience daily disrespect. Another best practice is to not inquire about the particulars related to their bodies or surgeries as this is personal. Practice using the correct pronouns or correcting yourself and apologizing when a mistake occurs. Acknowledging and correcting are two important actions you can take. The presenters offered several dialogue scenarios to illustrate how to do this with your language used.
The last section of the session focused on policies and practices of inclusion within the library. There were many wonderful examples that Micah offered:
- Offering programs and spaces beyond Pride month. This may include things like book talks or library displays all year long.
- When celebrating other months incorporate trans folks (such as women’s history month – include trans women)
- Include trans folks within trainings as speakers as well as include trans authors within your collections
- When developing these programs or services, include trans folks in the planning and implementation
- Ensure that your ILS is trans affirming
- Improving restroom accessibility and knowing where the nearest gender restroom is located
- Represent trans folks from all communities
This session included discussion of key areas: 1) understanding transgender issues and the variety of gender identities, 2) use of gendered language, 3) best practices for working with transgender patrons and colleagues, and 4) considering policies of inclusion. Resources and readings to improve interactions and services with transgender patrons and co-workers were offered so that we can continue to improve ourselves, organizations and support our transgender communities.